Israel Policy Pod
A weekly podcast that goes beyond the headlines to bring you analysis from Israel Policy Forum experts and distinguished guests.
Israel Policy Pod
The Future of the U.S.-Israel Relationship
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
On this episode of Israel Policy Pod, host and Tel Aviv-based journalist Neri Zilber is joined by Israel Policy Forum’s Executive VP for Policy and Government Relations, Rachel Brandenburg. They unpack what drove Democrats’ sweeping midterm victory, how much Israel mattered to voters, and how Republicans are explaining their historic defeat. They also discuss what the new Democratic majorities in Congress are likely to do in the coming months, what’s at stake for the U.S.-Israel security assistance agreement, and what Israel’s next government will need to do to repair ties in Washington.
Read our report on the next U.S.-Israel security agreement here.
Follow us on Instagram, Twitter/X, and Bluesky, and subscribe to our email list here.
Welcome And The Big Question
NeriShalom and welcome to the Israel Policy Pod. I'm Neri Zilber, a journalist based in Tel Aviv and a policy advisor to Israel Policy Forum. What does the future hold for the U.S.-Israel relationship? Rachel Brandenburg, IPF's Executive Vice President for Policy and Government Relations, based in Washington, and a former senior U.S. government official is back with us this week to help explain what the recent U.S. bitter results, the blue tsunami as it's called, actually mean for the U.S. Israel relationship, what we can expect from a Democratic Party in the coming months and years, and how a new Israeli government, any Israeli government, can work to repair ties. The fate of the U.S. Israel relationship is obviously a very timely and hugely important issue for many people, but especially for listeners of this podcast and for Israel Policy Forum more generally. Rachel was terrific in breaking it all down for us. And let's be clear, this is only the beginning of the conversation. This issue isn't going away. Far from
Lieberman And Israel’s Political Spiral
Neriit. Before we get to Rachel, let's do a quick reporter's notebook where I take you behind the scenes and on the ground into the stories that are shaping current events and the big policy moves here in Israel and beyond. So there have been many famous and infamous dates all across the history of the Middle East. May 14, 1948, June 5th, 1967, September 13th, 1993, one of my favorite dates, October 7th, 2023, obviously, and November 2nd, uh, 1917. Uh and many, many more. These are just a few. But it's probably fair to say that November 14, 2018 will not rank up there with all these other momentous dates. Uh and to be clear, I'm not arguing that it should, but it's worth looking back and highlighting the seemingly random and unremarkable date from eight years ago. And for that, uh, we need to thank uh Vido Lieberman. Lieberman, as most of you know, is the head of the Israel al-Baytinu party. He's one of the leaders of the current Israeli opposition and a former foreign and defense minister here in Israel. And way back in November 2018, he resigned that post of defense minister in Bibi Netanyahu's government in protest at Gaza policy. There had just been a two-day escalation with Hamas and Bibi, as they always did before October 7th, 2023, cut a deal, went to a quick ceasefire, and continued with his long-standing Gaza policy, basically cash for quiet. This was way too much for Lieberman, who resigned in protest to this day, and to Lieberman's credit, the only Israeli official to do so prior to October 7th, quitting in protest and on principle over Gaza policy, which uh is remarkable to think about, but yes, Lieberman was an outlier. So, okay, why am I telling you all of this? Because a few weeks after Lieberman's resignation, Netanyahu's then government officially collapsed, new elections were called, and I'm not exaggerating here, nothing was ever the same. Those subsequent elections in the spring of 2019 were the first of five elections that took place here in less than four years. Five elections in less than four years. We all remember them. And why were there so many elections? Because yet again, our friend David Lieberman famously and fully uh broke with Netanyahu's block in that initial April 2019 election, denying Bibi a government by one seat, one seat, primarily over the issue of the ultra-orthodox and matters of religion and state. Uh hold that thought. So November 14th, 2018. Not exactly a day that will live in infamy, uh, but it was, and now okay, I'm I'm exaggerating slightly for a fact, the last normal moment we had here in Israel. Uh repeat elections after repeat elections after repeat elections, ad nauseum, a pandemic, the most far-right government in Israeli history, the biggest domestic political turmoil in Israeli history with the judicial overhaul bid for much of 2023, the worst security failure in the country's history on October 7th, 2023, the longest war in Israeli history over the past, well, three plus years. Uh and there's a lot more that I'd left out just for time's sake. But uh trust me, the last uh many number of years here have been anything but calm and anything but normal. So fast forward to the present day, Lieberman is still front and center, the agent of chaos, as we like to call him on this podcast, playing some version of Game of Thrones that no one can quite understand yet. Uh the opposition late last night elected a new speaker of the Knesset, Matan Kahana from Ghadi Eisencott Sharpy. Uh, and that's all for the good. And by the way, this was accomplished. Kahana's election was accomplished with the support of the Arab-Israeli political parties. With those parties, there is a clear majority of 67 seats right there, right there in front of them, to form some kind of government led by a Gadi Eisencott. Again, there are various formulations to it, but the numbers are there with the Arab-Israeli parties. And yet, and yet, Lieberman so far refuses and has vetoed any cooperation with the Knesset members from the Arab political parties. Lieberman has now gone back on his years-long pledge regarding ultra-orthodox conscription into the IDF in a bid to entice the Haredim to join the opposition in a new government. And he even said this week, uh, amazingly, that he wanted to find a deal over conscription that was acceptable to the IDF, that was acceptable to the Haredi rabbis, and that can pass legal muster in front of the Supreme Court. All I have to say is uh good luck with all that. But Lieberman also said that his two main goals are ending the Netanyahu era once and for all and avoiding another repeat election. But the question has to be asked: what happens if the Haredi option blows up, doesn't come to fruition? What will Lieberman be willing to do then in order to, like he promised, end BB's political career and avoid another election? No one knows. No one knows the answer to that question, at least not yet. The agent of chaos strikes again in the present day, nearly eight years to the day after you first set all this in motion.
Rachel Brandenburg Joins The Pod
NeriWith that, let's get to Rachel Brandenburg. Hi, Rachel. Welcome back to the podcast. Hi,
RachelNeri. Thanks. It's great to be here.
NeriIt's really lovely to have you on. Uh, I also just saw you a few days ago in Israel. So uh a lot of uh IPF and Rachel time this past week. I never complain about that. But I wanted you on for a formal on the record podcast interview uh on the big issue of, well, recent weeks and especially this month, the U.S. midterm results, uh, what do they mean? Uh the US-Israel relationship, obviously, and the new, well, still non-existent Israeli government here on my end. And you were just here, you're based in Washington. So you have, I think, a really good and current perspective from uh both sides of the pond, uh, even though it's a very, very big pond. Some would even say an ocean uh and a continent, various continents. Um, but let's start here with the actual US midterm results of two weeks ago.
What The Midterms Were Really About
NeriFirst question: big picture. How should we understand them generally uh in terms of US politics and specifically as it relates to Israel? I hate to put it in these terms, but like, you know, uh Israelis always think it's about them. I venture to say it's not only about them slash us, but uh, how big of an issue was Israel really in this blue tsunami that swept over America this month?
RachelYeah, thanks, Neri. And you're right. I think Israelis do often think that everything is about them. Uh I got a lot of questions last week about, oh, you know, are are we are we out of luck now that the Democrats are coming to power? Uh and I think although discontent around Israel and US support for Israel has certainly played a role and taken a very prominent role in the political conversation in the United States over the past year, this election was not actually about Israel. This election was a repudiation of President Trump and President Trump's policies. And things like the cost of living, corruption, which has been rampant across his administration, tariffs that he has somewhat thoughtlessly placed on a number of our close trading partners, ICE conduct, the immigration policies, and the way the Immigration and Customs Enforcement Authority has behaved and plucked people off the street, including in traditionally Republican states. And also taking the United States on the sort of foreign adventure that President Trump campaigned against, that is the Iran War. And there too. There are some who will say the Iran war is all Israel's fault. And in turn, this actually was about Israel because the vote was about Iran. But the war itself was not as much the point as the impact it has had on Americans' lives. And those relate back to the things I mentioned: cost of living.
NeriGas prices, inflation.
RachelExactly. Gas prices, the price of fertilizer, inflation, things that hit traditional Republican areas even more than traditional Democratic areas, because agriculture has been affected, rural areas where you have to drive far distances. So these were really the core issues. I think, although we expected Democrats to take back the House, the extent to which they took back the people calling it a blue tsunami instead of a blue wave is reflective of the surprise, even for Democrats, and taking back the Senate. So Israel certainly has played a role in the political conversation, and I'm sure we'll get to that. It's a real issue. It's a real challenge, I think. It will be a real challenge for the U.S. Israel relationship moving forward. But that was not actually what the election was about.
NeriOkay. That's uh comforting to hear uh because obviously the coverage here in Israel was, well, all about Israel. And what does this mean? What does this mean about us?
RachelThat's right.
NeriUh and I had to explain, I explained to many Israeli friends, well, exactly what you just said, that uh someone may vote Democrat uh not because of Israel, or not vote Democrat not because of Israel. So it's really a good point to stress right from the outset. Uh just for our listeners and viewers, uh, who, well, we're an international podcast, as you know, Rachel. So just the the scale of the tsunami, the blue nami, Democrats have won 56 seats in the Senate. Republicans have 44, Republicans lost nine seats in the Senate alone, which is massive. Uh in the House, the Democrats have 257. You just need 218 for a majority. Uh, Republicans lost 43 seats and counting.
RachelI think
Neria few races are still outstanding. The Dems now also hold 30 out of 50 uh governorships. That's a gain of six, also quite remarkable. And as I'm sure people know, all of this came all over the country. I mean, in like red states like Texas,
RachelKansas,
NeriKansas, Alabama, Alaska. I mean, it it's really remarkable, just the scale of the tsunami, though.
RachelMississippi.
NeriMississippi. I mean, it just it kind of, I mean, I've been following American politics for long enough, and I do not remember anything like this. Yeah.
RachelSo
Neriagain, this may be obvious to our American viewers and listeners, but for our international and especially Israeli listeners and viewers, they need to kind of understand the scale of this.
RachelAnd I think just to put a finer point on that scale, when it comes to Congress, this is a larger majority for the Democrats than either party has had in a lot of years. So I'm sure we'll talk about what what the next Congress will look like. But the majorities have been in the single-digit too low double digits. And this, the numbers you just mentioned are are large.
NeriMassive, massive. Um, and really a wholesale repudiation of the first two years of Trump, Trump uh two.
RachelYeah.
NeriSo uh we we shall see what he does with the remaining uh two years of his administration. I think that may be uh beyond beyond the remit of uh of this podcast and maybe beyond the remit of anybody kind of trying to
Rachelit's probably beyond the imagination of either of us.
NeriRight.
Republicans Blame Israel And Iran
NeriUh a fail uh a future failure of imagination, as someone once said. Um let's look across the aisle at the Republicans and just uh coming out of the midterm results, Donald Trump himself, vice president J.D. Vance, other Republicans, and certainly other, let's say, right wing or far-right commentators, uh, like you said, very much emphasized the Iran war for the losses, right? Not anything, say, you know, their immigration policy and other tariffs, right? But very much the Iran war, with Trump adding uh in a recent interview that there was uh quote, great uh dislike of Israel out there and Vance calling for a re-evaluation of the relationship with Israel. So um, I mean, you're in Washington, I'm not, but do you think this is kind of a growing opinion amongst right-wingers and right-wing circles that Israel, writ large, whether kind of directly related to Iran or just Israeli policies and other arenas, was basically to blame for these massive losses?
RachelI think it is a growing opinion, but it's also reflective of Trump and his team wanting to blame somebody else for their problems, right? It's a it's a convenient scapegoat to say that Israel, a country whose support has already fallen in both Democrat and Republican circles long before the elections, Israel is to blame for their losses. It ignores all the things I mentioned before: their corruption, their tariffs, their immigration policy, the fact of fuel prices and fertilizer and other cost of living just being so much higher and more difficult for your average American. So it is a convenient scapegoat. That said, it also is reflective of a current in the Republican Party that is no longer blindly pro-Israel. Some of it comes from the America First wing of the party, particularly of the MAGA base, Trump's base, who view all engagements overseas as questionable, American interventions overseas as questionable, and think pretty fundamentally that taxpayer dollars should be spent on America. And if we are going to do anything overseas, there has to be a very tangible benefit to the United States. So that is related to Israel, and that is also related to just all foreign partners and foreign um engagements. And then there are, and I think you alluded to some of the commentators out there who are more extreme, white nationalists, who view Israel as a problem, who are anti-Semitic, who, you know, the list goes on. And that is also a growing current among the Republican Party. But this is not just because of the Iran War. And this is not just reflected in the election. There was a March 2026 poll put done by the Pew Research Center that reflected 50% 57% of Republicans age 18 to 49 have an unfavorable view of Israel, in comparison with only 24% of Republicans over 50. So this is a trend, but it's it's well beyond the elections.
NeriYeah, in the Republican Party, right? We're not even talking about a Democratic Party.
RachelThis is not Democrat. Democrat, the numbers were over 80% for the younger age cohort.
NeriYeah. It's um I mean, we talked about it in previous episodes, and it's kind of well known in many quarters, maybe less appreciated than it should be here in Israel. But yes, uh Israel standing across the entire political spectrum in America is plummeted, cratered.
RachelYes. And for some, it's Israel. For some, it's Israel's behavior, and therefore the government. So there's not sort of uniform reasons that Israel's star has fallen across either party.
NeriYeah, we're going to get uh into that very important and tricky question uh later on when we talk about um, well, looking ahead and kind of uh what the Israeli government, any Israeli government needs to do and whether this is just a kind of an Israel problem or maybe a government slash Netanyahu BB problem uh in America. Those were
What Democrats Will Try To Pass
Nerithe results. Let's look at the Congress moving forward, and the new Congress takes office uh in January. That's really where the center of gravity has shifted, despite the fact that, yes, the White House is still controlled by the Republican Donald Trump. So uh this is a two-part question, Rachel. I hate these, but we're gonna pose it this way. I mean, what do you think the Democratic majorities in both the House and Senate will actually do in terms of policy and agenda, um, related to Israel or or not? And the second part of the question is what do you think they can do in terms of policy, agenda, and the like, given the fact that yes, Trump still wields a veto? So two-part question.
RachelSure. So, first, beyond Israel, because as we said before, not everything in our politics here in America or our policies are about Israel. Um, there are issues that many members of Congress were elected on, particularly because the vast majority of members are not DSA and not progressives, they're moderate Democrats. And although some of the loudest races or some of the most prominently covered races focused heavily on Israel and people campaigned against, you know, or campaigned on getting rid of assistance to Israel and ending the US relationship with Israel, ultimately, because these were about the bread and butter breader issues for Americans, like cost of living, like health care, um, I think there will be a lot of pressure for both chambers, the House and the Senate, to try and legislate around things that relate to everyday Americans. So healthcare. I think there will also be a repudiation of the Iran war and an attempt to cut off all funding, to pass war powers resolutions that reflect across both parties a disconsent, discontent with uh Trump's war in Iran. And this will include Republicans and include, I think, a focus on Trump's war, not just this being a war that Israel dragged Trump into, which has been a narrative among elements on both sides of the uh Republican and Democrat parties. There will also be a long list of things to investigate. The Democrats have long been preparing the ways in which they will investigate corruption in the Trump administration. There are those who want to try and impeach Trump again. I think there's also a lot of pressure not to not to walk down the road of impeachment because that will just take all the oxygen out of the room and frankly hand the Republicans the opportunity to say, look, the Democrats aren't doing anything. They're just complaining about us. So we'll see which way that lands. And some of this and what ends up the priorities for the House and the Senate Democratic caucuses will depend on who ends up the leader of the House and the Senate. So in the Senate in particular, there's a bit of a competition right now between Schumer and Senator Van Halen, who has claimed that he has the votes and he wants to end up being the leader in the Senate. I don't know how likely that is, but a Van Halen-led Senate will probably have a slightly different agenda than a Schumer, than a Senator Schumer Schumer-led Senate.
NeriAnd by the way, Van Halen, very much more progressive to the left of Schumer on many issues, but especially
RachelEspecially in Israel.
NeriEspecially in Israel.
RachelYes. And despite these being, I think, the priorities that both chambers will try to legislate around, there will also be a lot of debate around Israel. I don't think we can kid ourselves. Just because Israel was not the reason that Democrats got elected, there is still a very significant uh current of support for ending security assistance to Israel, really looking critically at the relationship and holding the Israeli government's feet to the fire when it comes to policies that many American legislators don't think are in interest of the United States, particularly while we give them so much security assistance. So we've already seen a number of bills come to the floor over the past few months prior to the elections, prior to our elections, that relate to sanctions, for example, on settlements or settlement constructions. Some of those are very, very broad. Some of them relate specifically to E1, for example. We've also seen legislation come to the floor on arm sales, whether preventing or conditioning arm sales to Israel. And then there still is a question, and I think we'll probably talk more about this, about the last couple of years of the current memorandum of understanding. So although the MOU was agreed for 10 years, the funding for that MOU still needs to be appropriated by Congress.
NeriAnd
Rachelthat is already a question. Will they be able to appropriate the next couple of years? What will that look like? I don't think we know the answer to that yet, but it will be a difficult debate.
NeriSo uh just for our audience, uh the MOU is basically the memorandum of understanding. It's the US Israel security assistance deal. Um, we'll get to that in just a moment. Uh you mentioned E1, Rachel. That's this controversial settlement proposal east of Jerusalem, basically between Jerusalem and the Maledumim settlement block in the West Bank. Uh highly controversial. Uh the current Israeli government has moved forward with planning and tenders for starting construction there. So far it's been delayed by the Attorney General here in Israel, but obviously um, well, not just in Washington, but also in many European capitals. They hyper focused on that particular settlement plan. Um, because the argument is that it will uh basically preclude any future contiguous Palestinian state in the West Bank.
RachelRight. Even though it's not that big of an area, it's it's it has such um significant popular recognition.
NeriRight. East of uh Jerusalem, connecting Jerusalem to Maladumim. Um and I mean you talked about these various bills that have either been tabled or perhaps proposed moving forward. So going back to my original inelegant two-part question, right? So in your mind, will this new Congress That takes office in January actually move ahead with some slash all of these bills? Will it depend on the leadership? And even if it's passed by this, you know, heavily, heavily democratic Congress, can we expect Trump just to veto it?
RachelYes. So that's like three questions in one now.
NeriYeah. Even more inelegant.
RachelThree or four. Yes, I do think we can expect some version of these bills to come to the floor. Exactly what version? Because there's a pretty pretty wide spectrum of versions that have already been introduced and people already thinking about who will introduce the next versions and what will they look like. Some of the details will depend on who's in power in Israel. I think if there is a failure to form a government, if Israel goes back to elections and Netanyahu remains in charge, or if Netanyahu ends up the one to form a government, then uh the conversation looks very different.
NeriGotcha.
RachelThe moderate Democrats, in particular those who consider themselves traditionally pro-Israel and really want to find a way forward in a constructive way that maintains the bilateral relationship and the strength of the bilateral relationship, are gonna have a very hard time doing that if Netanyahu remains the prime minister. If there's a new government led by Gatti Eisencott, that is one step in the right direction of providing window of opportunity. But ultimately, the change in leadership is critical, but not sufficient. Sort of a necessary but insufficient element. There also needs to be a change of behavior and a pretty quick change in behavior, even if just rhetorically initially and committing to do things differently. Because from the perspective of a lot of American legislators, Democrat in particular, but also Republicans, they have been holding back a dam of discontent and desire to pass sanctions legislation and condition arms sales for a while. And Netanyahu has not done any favors or helped them in any way. That said, what can Trump do? Or what can Congress actually do while Trump is in charge? It's more limited. They do have to be the ones to appropriate funding. So they cannot appropriate funding or they can place conditions on funding. And Trump can't really veto, he can't veto the lack of appropriation. He can veto sanctions bills, he can veto arm sales conditions, but I think we also have to remember this is the beginning of a conversation that is not just about this next Congress, it's about the presidential elections in 2028. So what we're seeing now and what we'll see over the next year will also be informed by those who are deciding to campaign and what motivates the campaign conversations as they relate to Israel. And again, that will be informed by who the Israeli, who the next Israeli government is and how they behave and whether they can regain some favor uh here in the United States. But this is going to be a campaign issue, whether we like it or not.
NeriUndoubtedly, undoubtedly so. Um we'll touch on 2028 in just a second. Final question in terms of the current Congress and I guess the for you know the coming months. Um, well, the new Congress in the coming months. Give us a sense, I mean, to the best of your understanding, what is the balance of power between, like you said, the more moderate Democrats that hew to maybe a more traditional policy vis-a-vis Israel to more progressives, to, I mean, we hear about obviously uh senator elect from Michigan, Abdullah Saed, uh, you hear about the Democratic Socialist of America, uh, obviously they these um candidates and now elected officials soak up a lot of the oxygen in the media debate, but how reflective are they, to your mind, of what we're gonna see in on Capitol Hill come January?
Moderates, Progressives, And Real Votes
RachelSo there are different flavors of progressive, in addition to different flavors of Democrat. Those, the DSA candidates, are the minority, those for whom Israel is a problem. It doesn't really matter whether Israel behaves differently or there's a new government, the issue is Israel and US support for Israel. There are also those, and they are more numerous, for whom Israel's behavior is a problem. And that is the Israeli government's behavior and a new government who behaves differently and speaks differently. And we can talk about what that means in my mind also, but that will make the conversations slightly easier, but still there's not looking for blind or blanket support of Israel. Uh, I think the Israeli conduct in Gaza and around the region has been a problem. Uh, and that is going to be difficult, if not impossible, to reverse quickly. I think that's a much longer conversation that's going to take a number of years to change. And then there are those who are candidly fewer in number who I think we think of as kind of the traditional pro-Israel Dems for whom the relationship is important, almost regardless of who's in charge, because they understand the strategic importance of Israel for the United States. Those are fewer in number than they were previously, with one caveat, and that is a lot of the moderate Democrats who were elected don't necessarily have a track record on Israel. And so for them, this will be a learning opportunity. And in terms of politics and how the Senate and House leadership will decide to govern, what they'll decide to pass and bring to the floor for votes, because of the large majority that we talked about way early on in the conversation, how the Democrats have so many more senators and members and members in the House than the Republicans, and a pretty large margin, everybody doesn't need to vote the same way anymore. The large margin of Democrats enables people to vote a little bit differently and bills still pass. This means that maybe a settlement sanctions bill that is not as punitive, that is what we would consider a lighter version of the spectrum of bills, uh, could pass, even if a handful of Democrats and all the Republicans vote against it. So that actually provides a bit more flexibility to the leadership to introduce things that they think are good policy rather than have to pander to the extremes of either side of their party, which I think for the sake of the Israel conversation will make the actual legislating a little bit easier, but not uncomplicated.
NeriOkay. So that's uh good news of a sort. The wide margins uh that the Dems have both in the Senate and House could kind of uh mitigate the influence of the more
Rachelof any single member.
NeriRight. That can hold another bill hostage if their demands with regard to Israel are not are not met.
RachelAnd I guess just to add one other thought, this doesn't mean that we won't continue to hear a lot of noise. And I think the races, and this includes some of the DSA DSA candidates outside, you know, he's a very good speaker, he's a very good politician, although he does not reflect the majority in the Senate among Democrats, he will continue to be out there. Uh and so I think it will be important for us to distinguish between what is the noise and the conversation, and what is real political sentiment and sort of the real political conversation that's happening, and then what is actually legislation and what are the things that are actually coming to the floor with the intent to become law.
NeriYes. Um, it's an issue we have here in the Knesset as well. A lot of noise, very rarely does it become policy and or bills, and then even more rare it is a government policy, although the last four years have taught us maybe a bit uh a bit differently.
Disputed Territory Podcast Break
ShanieTalking about Israel has gotten so hard. People are angry and dug into their positions, and most of the time it feels like the conversation is over before it even begins. But what if we kept talking? I'm Shady Reichmann from Israel Policy Forum, and this is Disputed Territory, a podcast for real talk about Israel.
SPEAKER_03I don't find that shaming people works very well and getting them to listen to you. What I try to do is at least open up a space that people can listen. I also try to ask people questions to like push them to ask themselves to evaluate their own ideologies.
ShanieWe can believe that there needs to be an is a Jewish state and also work every day to make it better. And I see my work as really digging in there, trying to fix the hardest and most challenging parts of Israel. And it doesn't take away from loving it.
SPEAKER_04You can call these things wrong, you can call these things unacceptable, one, two, et cetera, but you should not dehumanize it in church.
ShanieWe're going to talk about Zionism, the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, Jewish identity, the relationship between American Jews and Israel, and the questions that don't always have easy answers. You'll hear from people with different perspectives. Sometimes I'll agree with them and other times I won't. But that's the point.
SPEAKER_05When I criticize Antonio and Beginfear and the settlements, and when I speak about a two-state solution, all of this is because of my love for the Jewish people.
SPEAKER_06I feel like my responsibility is to be a diaspora Jew and to stay compassionate and to stay nuanced. Why that is so incredibly difficult in this moment, I don't know.
ShanieI believe the conversations about Israel don't have to drive us apart. They might actually be the only productive way forward. This is disputed territory, real talk about Israel. Follow along on Apple, YouTube, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
Can Congress Actually Stop The War
NeriLet me ask you a question. You mentioned something almost in passing, and I've heard this too that the Democrats, maybe even before the new Congress, perhaps in the next couple of weeks, but definitely after the new year with the new Congress, are going to try to pass legislation cutting off funding for the Iran War. That sounds ominous, although I was told, you know, it's not like kind of flicking a switch.
RachelRight.
NeriAnd you uh, you know, you cut f you cut funding and then you know aircraft carriers have to like shut their engines and turn around. Uh I was told that it doesn't work that way in the American system. So what do you think, let's say, the the Dems, whether the current Congress or the new Congress are able to pass this this bill, what do you think that actually means?
RachelSo most likely what we'll see is uh a war powers resolution, which basically says the president is in violation of the law if he continues conducting a war. And you're right, they can't, I mean, they they can fail to appropriate funding, but there's a tension here because our troops, our service members actually are in the field and are, you know, you can't you can't end funding and therefore end our engagement with our adversaries. It doesn't work that way. And as phrase I learned working in the Department of Defense, the enemy has a vote, right? So
Neriif
Rachelwe are seen to be simply cutting off our own legs at the knees, then the adversary we're ostensibly fighting also can do things to challenge that. I also don't see President Trump and his administration as particularly caring about the law. So although I do expect there to be wide support for a vote against the war, it doesn't mean that it's just gonna end tomorrow. And ultimately that will be up to the administration, the Trump administration, to determine how to how to engage that. There's also a lot of talk of trying to impeach the Secretary of Defense. So that too will be a big political conversation here that actually could lead to his ouster, or President Trump could decide that his star has fallen so far that it's time to let him go, though we're not seeing any indication of that.
NeriYeah.
RachelBut just because Congress votes against the war doesn't mean that our troops are suddenly gonna come home or our carriers that are currently in the Middle East are gonna turn around immediately.
NeriOkay. I think that's good news for some. By the way, just out of curiosity, why what is the basis for which the Democrats want to impeach Pete Hegseth, Secretary of Defense?
RachelOh, so many factors. Um, a combination of his leading the country to, I mean, ultimately the president is the commander-in-chief. So it was his decision to go to war. But Hegseth conduct has not exactly been admirable. He has also, frankly, gutted the department and the military of some very key senior leaders on the basis of all sorts of things, some of which he's tried to come up with excuses for, some of which he really hasn't. It's been, uh, a campaign against diversity in some of our senior ranks in a way that has been detrimental to our military and frankly offensive to sort of US and democratic values.
NeriOkay. That is a uh a very clear and concise answer. Uh I had to ask.
The MOU And Security Aid Uncertainty
NeriRachel, let's get to the big ticket issue/slash question, the MOU that we mentioned earlier, uh, the US Israel Security Assistance Agreement. These run for 10 years, traditionally. The last one was signed by then President Barack Obama back in 2018. Uh, so it was set to run for another two years from now. Uh, and yet, as uh I guess everyone probably already knows, on election morning two weeks ago, Donald Trump gave an interview and said, uh, the MOU was ending at the end of this year, December 31st, 2026. So, I mean, the first question, is that actually true? Is the MOU gonna be ending?
RachelSo nobody, nobody knows for sure what Trump means at most times when he says things, but it seems very dubious that it will end at the end of this calendar year for a few reasons. Um, one is simply a lot of the money that is that was um part of the next two years of the MOU has already been obligated. This has been reported in the press that there are contracts that have been signed that that account for the funding that hasn't actually been appropriated by Congress yet, but by all historical precedent, precedent, excuse me, the expectation was would be appropriated. And so if the money ends at the end of this year, not only are you going to cut off some of the um procurement processes, the ways that we sell and and give things to our partners uh midway through, but you're also going to leave a bunch of private defense companies without funds. Right. And someone has to cover that. I also don't, I maybe you know better than I, but I don't think I can't imagine a world in which for the Israeli security enterprise it is acceptable for funding just to be cut off at the end of the year without any plan for what to do about those contracts, those, you know, the there's so many things that go into our defense relationship and security assistance packages, similar to you can't just flip a switch and end a war. It's really hard to just flip a switch and end an active relationship, an active procurement process. Um, what did he mean? Did he mean the end of this calendar year? Did he mean the end of the fiscal year, which would be the end of next September? Um, that seems a little bit more palatable, but still questionable. Uh, but ultimately the next two years of the funding that is um sort of promised, committed in the memorandum of understanding, depend on Congress appropriating that funding. So this is an active conversation now among both parties, but certainly Democrats. What is that conversation going to look like? Are they gonna be able to pass an appropriations bill that includes the funding for Israel, given all of the discontent around that funding that we've already talked about? Is there going to be some deal that you pass the next couple of years of funding, but then you begin setting different terms for a next memorandum of understanding? And in the meantime, from everything we hear, the Trump administration and the Israeli government are negotiating a next MOU, which doesn't actually itself have to be voted on by Congress. That's that's up to the administration. It can be an agreement between two executives, between the Israeli government and the US government, without Congress playing a role, unless they have to appropriate funding. And that's where the rubber will really hit the road with respect to all that we've talked about in the next Congress.
NeriRight. And so a couple of things. Um the yearly kind of dollar amount of the MOU that was signed by by Obama now eight years ago, $3.8 billion a year. That's like the kind of ticket price. But uh only, well, only $3.3 billion. Um is basically uh what the Israelis call like free money. So Israel kind of is allocated that money and it can use that $3.3 billion to buy basically US weapons.
RachelYes.
NeriRight. So it's kind of um a workaround subsidy for US defense contractors, US jobs, and also we should say, very, very important for Israel and the IDF and its ability to kind of have the most cutting-edge platforms. So that uh well, that may be in trouble. The remaining $500 million per year is used for kind of joint development projects.
RachelMissile defense specifically.
NeriYeah, missile missile defense, right? Iron Dome, uh, arrow. So also very important, but kind of a different type of arrangement. And basically since January, BB Netanyahu said it publicly. Uh I reported it at the time, I think January, February. I mean, BB said, okay, we're going to kind of renegotiate the future MOU, but it's going to be very different. Uh that it's going to be now uh what do you what do you call it? From uh from assistance to partnership, from aid to partnership.
RachelI think there was a sexier phrase, but yes, that was the gist of it.
NeriThat was the gist of it. So it'd be um no more free money, as it's called here, and more joint development projects, which I think is uh is is probably all for the good, but obviously BB
RachelI think it was aid to trade. Uh aid to trade.
NeriAid to trade? I mean it's not really trade.
RachelIt's not really trade, but I think that was the phrase that they were using.
NeriI mean, BB is nothing if not a um well, a very skillful politician. I think he already saw kind of the direction of travel in America. Uh by the way, not just among Democrats, but also maybe Donald Trump himself. Uh not a huge fan of foreign aid uh full stop. So these were negotiations were ongoing. Um and I can tell you, Rachel, I you I think you heard this from Israelis when you were here last week, but the entire establishment here, uh both the military and otherwise, were just blindsided. They didn't nobody nobody knows what Donald Trump was talking about. I think, least of all, well, maybe BB Nentanyaho, but I I doubt even that. So yeah, we have to r wait and see if there is going to be a this renegotiated MOU. Um I think the dollar amount will be far less, but it may be uh uh like a partnership.
RachelYeah, and it's important to note that there, uh in my opinion, that makes sense, right? Each prior MOU has been used to transition the bilateral relationship from one phase to another. So the first one was about transitioning off economic assistance and onto security assistance. This last one was in the context of the Iran war. It was a whole, you know, a whole set of political and policy issues, but it really ramped up security assistance. It also transitioned Israel off of a pretty unique permission structure that it was allowed to use our dollars. So US, you you said Israelis call it free money. We call it foreign military financing. That's
Nerithe official
Rachelterm. So they, but Israel for a time was allowed to use US foreign military financing to pay for things in its own industry, which is unusual. And that opportunity, uh, it's called offshore procurement, that has been graduated down. So by the end of this MOU, Israel now has to spend US foreign military financing on US defense industry. That's that's where it is now. As you said, that makes that it that subsidizes American defense production and jobs, et cetera. And so it, I think, given where Israel is economically, given where the relationship is, makes good sense for a next MOU or some form of agreement between the two countries to transition the relationship from the sort of assistance provider, recipient, to partners. And whether that's security partners, that shared RD, uh joint production, the missile defense is important not only for Israel, but also for us. And so there are real benefits to the United States from the cooperation on many levels, including the innovation that comes from Israel. But ending it tomorrow or ending it at the end of this calendar year and simply saying we're done is a very different prospect than some sort of agreement that graduates assistance from where it is now to nothing over a number of years.
NeriAnd in terms of the kind of the upside benefits to the US and US security and kind of the value added that Israel could bring, I mean, do you think that argument's gonna get a fair hearing in Washington next year?
RachelNo. To be blunt, I think it's gonna be very difficult. I think uh everything I've said previously still stands. A new Israeli government who speaks differently, behaves differently, engages differently is gonna be critical. And then sort of proving again to the US and to the US public and US legislature why the relationship matters. I think those sort of the bucket of politicians I mentioned previously who are traditionally pro-Israel and understand implicitly the strategic value of the US-Israel relationship are far fewer. Uh, and that is in a prior generation of leadership that is not reflected in a lot of the younger members and a lot of the new members. So it will be up to the Israeli government to actually convince Americans and American politicians why the relationship is important and what value we derive, and also an understanding that while we do share a lot of interests between the United States and Israel, we don't share all interests. And what is good for Israel is not necessarily what is good for the United States, and vice versa. So a recognition that we are each sovereign nations who have our own views on the world and our own politics and our own policies, I think is important and has not been reflected in Netanyahu's. Rhetoric about, you know, let's take the Iran war as an example. But that there is a point at which our interests diverge, and that's okay. Uh
How Israel Starts Repairing Trust
Neriso I mean the big question, jumping off from that point, let's say a new Israeli government is formed tomorrow. It's not it's not going to be formed tomorrow. But let's say, okay, in the coming weeks, uh Gadi Isencott, um, or even Bibi Netanyahu, but that's I think a different conversation. But like any new Israeli government, what to your mind does that government need to do to actually begin repairing ties with America?
RachelUm, yeah, there's there's a long list. And
Nerithat that that sci that side says it all,
Rachelright? There's some real basics, like engage Americans openly, honestly, and respectfully. That has not been Netanyahu's MO. And it has certainly
Nerithat he's made Israel kind of a divisive partisan issue
Rachelin
Nerithe conversation.
RachelHe chose years ago to bet on the Republicans and basically, you know, view the Democrats as not relevant and not important for engagement. And I think we're seeing in in a big way how short-sighted that was. I think you also need to be able to speak honestly and um transparently, whether in private or in public, about some of the challenges in Israel. I think our elections here in the US showed us that there still is a desire for and a respect for democracy. Israel's elections also, they're sort of the turnout, the um diversity of turnout. We could talk about the Israeli elections another time, so I won't get into it, but there's uh a shared set of values, I think, that exist across the public that have not been reflected in either of our leaderships. But an Israeli government who speaks about restoring respect for democratic values could go a long way in the public conversation here, to say nothing of the Trump administration, who should do the same, but I have no expectation will. Uh, and then there are some policy issues where things like first and foremost, restoring law and order in the West Bank,
Neriholding
RachelJewish terrorists accountable for the violence that they're committing against innocent Palestinians. That has really, it's really shocked people across every sector of American political conversation, the from those who are sort of staunchly pro-Israel to those who are staunchly anti-Israel. It's the idea that there are, as Netanyahu will say, a handful of, you know, misguided youth, right, who who just have found the wrong way. And they can't actually the that with that said, the Israeli law enforcement establishment can't find them or get a hold of them or arrest them at the same time as they can like literally put a missile into a window to find someone in Tehran is kind of unbelievable.
NeriIt's a joke.
RachelSo that is one thing that I think would go a long way. Working with the Palestinian Authority with all of its issues and with all of its challenges, stabilizing the finances in the Palestinian economy and reflecting a policy that does not aspire to collapse the Palestinian Authority. Again, these are basics, um, but could go a long way. Releasing the clearance revenues that are owed to the Palestinian Authority, so the tax revenues that Israel collects that are owed to the Palestinian Authority that have been withheld by the Israeli government for the past couple of years. And then we talked about E1 and settlement construction. Maintaining the freeze on E1 would be a good step. You know, it would be very politically difficult to reverse entirely. There are hundreds of illegal outposts that have been stood up over the past four years, removing those that you can remove and freezing the establishment of new ones. These are all things that reflect at least an interest in preserving the possibility of resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and not killing the possibility of resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. And then on Gaza, that too is an area that has commanded a lot of attention, letting in critical humanitarian assistance, particularly as winter is basically here. We saw last week what flooding did to the tents that many Gazans are living in. And working with the Board of Peace, which is a Trump initiative, uh, and therefore has certainly the support of Republicans. It's kind of complicated on the Democratic side, but the desire for Gaza to be stabilized and secure is not complicated. I think Democrats and Republicans alike want either the Board of Peace to succeed because it's Trump's initiative or because it is good for Gazans. And there are some sort of basic steps that a new government could allow for and just reflect trying to work constructively with the Board of Peace for the sake of making progress in Gaza. I could go on. The list is long, but I
NeriI I was gonna prompt you anyway to give to give like a list of concrete policy moves and really changes that any new Israeli government needed to take. Uh, I think that's a good start. I think I think the list is longer than that. Um by the way, just on the Board of Peace in Gaza, I
unknownmean,
Nerithis is a deal that Netanyahu himself agreed to. So
Rachelas you said, he's a very good politician.
NeriHe's a very good politician. Uh he's also a very lucky politician, but that's um, you know, having to do with uh the caliber of his opponents here, here and in other places. But that's uh I think uh topic for a different podcast. No, but I think uh all cutting aside, I think I think those are, how did you put it earlier? Those are necessary but not sufficient steps to start beginning mending uh the relationship. Uh and if and when a new Israeli government comes into being sometime this century, uh they need to actually take that very seriously.
RachelYeah. Uh
NeriRachel, final
2028 And The Future Political Map
Neriquestion to you. Uh 2028, uh Donald Trump still has two more years, but um we assume he's not going to be president uh for another term. Uh what do you expect uh to come down the pike in terms of the presidential primaries on both sides, right? Amongst Democrats and also Republicans. Obviously, there's still a lot of time and things can change, but you even hear uh senior Israeli officials and even you know and others saying, well, we have two years to accomplish everything because after Trump, the flood. So what do you think 2028, the actual presidential race will look like?
RachelI think it's really hard to predict uh who will end up at the fore of the Democratic primary. There are those who will say every senator is running for president. Um
Nerievery senator maybe think he's gonna, he or she may be running for president.
RachelThat's correct. The list of those who have either been speculated or interested or indicated an interest is long. And what the presidential race looks like depends who the candidate ends up being. You know, Van Holland, Senator Van Holland, who we talked about earlier, had been rumored as among a presidential hopefuls. He just recently said he's no longer interested in president because he's focused on becoming speaker. If he doesn't speak become speaker, does that change?
NeriSenate Senate majority leader. I'm sorry,
RachelSenate Majority Leader.
NeriYes.
RachelYes, Senate Majority Leader.
NeriSee, I still remember, I still remember Washington politics.
RachelThat's right. Yeah.
NeriAnd
RachelI was just talking about the Knesset speaker this morning. So, you know, it's all jumbled up. But a Van Halen president, for example, or an AOC presidential candidate, for example, is very different than a Josh Shapiro presidential candidate or a a Newsom presidential candidate. So I think that, and particularly on Israel, the tenor of the conversation around Israel that comes from those candidates will depend on who it is. But the pressure on those candidates to express a position on Israel and on the future of the relationship and on the future of the assistance that the United States does or doesn't give Israel will be very high.
SPEAKER_05Right.
RachelAnd not too dissimilar on the Republican side. A JD Vance presidential candidate looks different than a Rubio presidential candidate, looks different than a, you know, who knows who else comes out of the woodwork. So in any of those cases, the relationship and the conversation around Israel, I think, is changed for the long term. And it will not look the same as it did two, three years ago. But how exactly that changes will depend on who the candidate is and how the Israeli government, whomever is at the helm of it, behaves over these next two years.
NeriI couldn't agree more. I think that's a great place to end. Um, Rachel, thank you for coming on and breaking it all down for us.
RachelThank you.
NeriAnd uh send my best to everyone back in in Washington.
RachelOf course.
NeriAnd uh we'll see uh well, we'll see what the outgoing Congress does in the next coming weeks and then the new Congress in January. And also a big factor will be um the politics on my end.
RachelThat's right. We're all we're all waiting with bated breath.
NeriEveryone's waiting. By the way, everyone was waiting. We know this for a fact, right? Officials in Washington were waiting for October 27th, election day here in Israel, by the way, not just in Washington, but also all across Europe and other places, Arab world as well. Um and and Israeli politics uh in fabulous classic fashion uh has not provided a very clear-cut result. So everyone, everyone including us are still waiting.
RachelAs they say, it's complicated.
NeriIt is complicated. But thank you for clarifying at least the US-Israel side of all this.
RachelMy
Thanks, Feedback, And Closing Notes
Rachelpleasure.
NeriOkay, thanks again to Rachel Brandenburg for her generous time and insights. Also, special thanks to our producer, Jacob Gilman, and to our editor, Tracy Levy, as always, and to all of you who support Israel Policy Forum's work. Just a reminder, you can email us with any feedback or questions at policypod at ipforum.org. That's policypod at ipforum.org. And do consider making a donation to Israel Policy Forum so it can keep being a credible source of analysis and ideas on issues such as these that we all care deeply about, including this podcast. And most importantly, thank you for listening. Please, please subscribe and spread the word. And most importantly, happy Thanksgiving to all those celebrating